TOP 10 RANKING
Top 10 Ice Cream Flavors — Ranked by Fans
Vanilla is the #1 fan-ranked Ice Cream Flavors on SendMeYourList, followed by Mint Chocolate Chip and Cookies and Cream. See the full community Top 10 and rank them yourself.
Rankings built from real SendMeYourList.com activity
Last updated: May 7, 2026
Vanilla leads the community rankings for Ice Cream Flavors, with Mint Chocolate Chip and Cookies and Cream close behind. These standings reflect real votes from SendMeYourList fans — not editors, not algorithms. Rank the full list yourself and see how your picks compare.
Rankings are determined entirely by real fan votes — no editors, no algorithms, no sponsorships. See exactly how the voting system works.
01
Vanilla – Classic perfection! The original flavor that's anything but boring - pure, creamy heaven.
02
Mint Chocolate Chip – Cool mint meets chocolate - from Ice Cream
03
Cookies and Cream – Oreo dreams come true! Crushed cookie pieces in vanilla perfection since the 1970s.
04
Strawberry – The original classic Pop-Tart flavor!
05
Neapolitan – Why choose one? Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry together in tricolor harmony since 1800s.
06
Rocky Road – Chocolate ice cream meets marshmallows and almonds - bumpy delicious journey in every bite.
07
Salted Caramel – Sweet meets salty perfection! Modern classic combining caramel ribbons with sea salt magic.
08
Butter Pecan – Buttery heaven with toasted pecans - sophisticated sweet and nutty Southern charm.
09
Coffee – Espresso energy in frozen form - caffeinated adult sophistication in every creamy spoonful.
10
